Whisky Tasting-Notes: Punkte
Scotch, Bourbon, Irish - was denn nun?
Das ist eigentlich vollkommen egal. Mit schottischem Single Malt (Scotch) hat man sicherlich eine der größten Vielfalten an Aromaprofilen, dennoch sind bei den anderen Gattungen einige sehr gute Kompositionen dabei. Also warum sich auf eine Art festlegen? Bei uns kommt auch jede Sorte ins Glas - alles andere wäre doch langweilig.
# World Class
92
- Glenturret 30 Year Old 1987/2018 Xtra Old Particular - Douglas Laing's (Marcel: 93 | Sascha: 90)
91
- Lagavulin 16 Year Old (Marcel: 89 | Sascha: 93)
- Talisker 18 Year Old (Marcel: 91 | Sascha: 91)
90
- Glenrothes 26 Year Old - Hart Brothers (Marcel: 90 | Sascha: 90)
- Redbreast 12 Year Old Cask Strength (2022) (Marcel: 92 | Sascha: 87)
# Excellent
89
- Kavalan King Car 40th Anniversary Edition (Marcel: 89 | Sascha: 89)
88
- Bookers Small Batch 2019 01E (Marcel: 85 | Sascha: 90)
- The Westfalian 10 Year Old Cask TW73 (Marcel: 88 | Sascha: 88)
87
- Octomore 10.3 2013 / 2019 6 Year Old (Marcel: 85 | Sascha: 89)
- Redbreast 15 Year Old (Marcel: 90 | Sascha: 84)
86
- Aultmore 13 Year Old - 82 Chapters to Newcastle (Creatures of Cask Strength) (Marcel: 88 | Sascha: 84)
- Wild Turkey Rare Breed (Marcel: 83 | Sascha: 89)
85
- Ardnamurchan AD:02.22 Peated Cask Strength (Marcel: 86 | Sascha: 83)
- Arran 10 Year Old (Marcel: 87 | Sascha: 82)
- Glen Scotia Double Cask (Marcel: 87 | Sascha: 83)
- Glenglassaugh 8 Year Old - The Cask Wizard (Marcel: 87 | Sascha: 83)
- Secret Speyside 13 Year Old - 82 Chapters to Newcastle (Creatures of Cask Strength) (Marcel: 87 | Sascha: 83)
84
- Ardbeg Corryvreckan (Marcel: 81 | Sascha: 87)
- Bulleit Bourbon 10 Year Old (Marcel: 81 | Sascha: 87)
- Dailuaine 10 Year Old (Brandambassador Phil) - 82 Chapters to Newcastle (Marcel: 83 | Sascha: 85)
- Glen Keith 21 Year Old (Marcel: 86 | Sascha: 81)
- Lochlea Cask Strength Batch 1 (Marcel: 85 | Sascha: 83)
- Redbreast 12 Year Old (Marcel: 85 | Sascha: 83)
- Talisker Port Ruighe (Marcel: 84 | Sascha: 83)
- The Westfalian Cask 121 (Marcel: 83 | Sascha: 85)
83
- Benromach 10 Year Old (Marcel: 83 | Sascha: 83)
- Laphroaig Brodir Final Batch (Marcel: 81 | Sascha: 85)
- The Balvenie 12 Year Old Doublewood (Marcel: 84 | Sascha: 81)
- The Westfalian Cask 134 (Marcel: 82 | Sascha: 84)
82
- Bruichladdich The Classic Laddie (Marcel: 83 | Sascha: 81)
- Lagavulin 11 Year Old Offerman Edition (Marcel: 80 | Sascha: 84)
- St. Kilian Signature Edition Nine (Marcel: 81 | Sascha: 83)
- Talisker 10 Year Old (Marcel: 83 | Sascha: 81)
81
- Annandale ManOSword Founders Selection Cask 348 2017 (Marcel: 81 | Sascha: 81)
- Elsburn The Journey 2021 (Marcel: 81 | Sascha: 81)
- Glendronach The Hielan 8 Year Old (Marcel: 81 | Sascha: 80)
- Speyburn 18 Year Old (Marcel: 80 | Sascha: 82)
80
- AnCnoc 12 Year Old (Marcel: 81 | Sascha: 78)
- Ardbeg Wee Beastie 5 Year Old (Marcel: 78 | Sascha: 82)
- Bunnahabhain Stiuireadair (Marcel: 80 | Sascha: 80)
- Lochlea Fallow Edition (First Crop) (Marcel: 79 | Sascha: 81)
- Lochlea Harvest Edition (First Crop) (Marcel: 80 | Sascha: 80)
- Mackmyra Intelligens AI:02 (Marcel: 79 | Sascha: 81)
- Scallywag 10 Year Old Small Batch Release - Douglas Laing's (Marcel: 80 | Sascha: 80)
- Scallywag Small Batch Release - Douglas Laing's (Marcel: 82 | Sascha: 78)
- St. Kilian Signature Edition Thirteen (Marcel: 82 | Sascha: 78)
- The Balvenie 15 Year Old Madeira Cask (Marcel: 80 | Sascha: 80)
# Very Good
79
- Ardbeg An Oa (Marcel: 75 | Sascha: 83)
- Ardnamurchan AD 10.21:06 (Marcel: 81 | Sascha: 77)
- Clynelish 14 Year Old (Marcel: 78 | Sascha: 80)
- Paul John Oloroso Select Cask (Marcel: 77 | Sascha: 81)
- Scallywag Chocolate Edition 2023 - Douglas Laing's (Marcel: 79 | Sascha: 79)
- St. Kilian Bud Spencer - The Legend - Rauchig - Batch 02 (Marcel: 78 | Sascha: 80)
- Starward Left-Field (Marcel: 79 | Sascha: 79)
- Wild Turkey 101 (Marcel: 78 | Sascha: 80)
78
- Craigellachie 13 Year Old Bas-Armagnac Cask Finish (Marcel: 79 | Sascha: 77)
- Kilkerran 12 Year Old (Marcel: 77 | Sascha: 79)
- Oban 14 Year Old (Marcel: 77 | Sascha: 79)
77
- Lochlea Our Barley (Marcel: 78 | Sascha: 76)
- Nikka Whisky From The Barrel (Marcel: 75 | Sascha: 79)
- Suntory Hibiki Harmony (Marcel: 78 | Sascha: 76)
76
- Ardbeg Scorch Committee Release (Marcel: 69 | Sascha: 83)
- Blade And Bow (Marcel: 75 | Sascha: 77)
- Dingle Single Malt Irish Whiskey (2021) (Marcel: 76 | Sascha: 76)
- Patrisbrunna Original Paderborner Single Malt 2016 (Marcel: 74 | Sascha: 77)
- Tomintoul 16 Year Old (Marcel: 76 | Sascha: 75)
75
- Berry Bros. & Rudd - Blended Malt Speyside (Marcel: 75 | Sascha: 75)
- Bulleit 95 Rye (Marcel: 73 | Sascha: 77)
- Caol Ila 12 Year Old (Marcel: 72 | Sascha: 78)
- Eagle Rare 10 Year Old (Marcel: 75 | Sascha: 75)
- Slipknot No.9 Whiskey (Marcel: 73 | Sascha: 77)
74
- Ardbeg Ardcore Committee Release (Marcel: 71 | Sascha: 77)
- Glen Elgin 12 Year Old (Marcel: 72 | Sascha: 76)
- Jack Daniel's Bonded (Marcel: 73 | Sascha: 75)
- Penderyn Madeira Finish (Marcel: 74 | Sascha: 74)
- Sea Shepherd (Marcel: 71 | Sascha: 77)
73
- Kinahans Irish Whiskey KASC Project Batch 03 (Marcel: 73 | Sascha: 73)
- Patrisbrunna Madeira Cask 2018 (Marcel: 72 | Sascha: 73)
- Talisker Surge (Marcel: 76 | Sascha: 70)
72
- Cragganmore 12 Year Old (Marcel: 68 | Sascha: 74)
- Glenkinchie 12 Year Old (Marcel: 68 | Sascha: 74)
- Glenmorangie 10 Year Old (Marcel: 69 | Sascha: 74)
- Patrisbrunna X-Mas Port 2016 Double Cask (Marcel: 70 | Sascha: 73)
71
- Jack Daniel's Single Barrel Select (Marcel: 69 | Sascha: 73)
- Knockando Richly Matured 15 Year Old - 2005 (Marcel: 71 | Sascha: 71)
70
- Royal Lochnagar 12 Year Old (Marcel: 69 | Sascha: 71)
- The Observatory 20 Year Old (Marcel: 69 | Sascha: 71)
# Good
69
- Apogee XII 12 Year Old (Marcel: 69 | Sascha: 69)
- Highland Park 15 Year Old Viking Heart (Marcel: 69 | Sascha: 69)
- Kavalan Distillery Select No.1 (Marcel: 69 | Sascha: 69)
- Lochlea Sowing Edition (Second Crop) (Marcel: 74 | Sascha: 63)
- North British 15 Year Old 2003 Mossburn No. 24 (Marcel: 71 | Sascha: 67)
- The Singleton Of Dufftown 12 Year Old (Marcel: 68 | Sascha: 70)
68
- Buffalo Trace (40%) (Marcel: 68 | Sascha: 68)
- Glenfiddich 12 Year Old (Marcel: 66 | Sascha: 70)
- Mackmyra Intelligens AI:01 (Marcel: 68 | Sascha: 68)
- Stork Club Straight Rye Whiskey (Marcel: 65 | Sascha: 71)
67
- Ardmore Port Wood Finish 12 Year Old (Marcel: 67 | Sascha: 67)
- Rock Island Small Batch Release - Douglas Laing's (Marcel: 55 | Sascha: 79)
66
- Aberfeldy 12 Year Old (Marcel: 67 | Sascha: 65)
- Knockando 12 Year Old (Marcel: 65 | Sascha: 67)
- Provenance Blair Athol 10 Year Old - Douglas Laing's (Marcel: 65 | Sascha: 67)
65
- Starward Octave Barrels The Octavius 2018 / 2021 3 Years Old (Marcel: 65 | Sascha: 65)
63
- Dalwhinnie 15 Year Old (Marcel: 62 | Sascha: 60)
61
- Ben Bracken Highland Peated (Marcel: 60 | Sascha: 62)
- Johnnie Walker Black Label 12 Year Old (Marcel: 61 | Sascha: 61)
60
- Cardhu 12 Year Old (Marcel: 56 | Sascha: 64)
- Johnnie Walker Black Label 12 Year Old Sherry Finish (Marcel: 57 | Sascha: 63)
- Roslagswhisky EKO Sherry Oloroso 2x30 2015-2022 (Marcel: 59 | Sascha: 61)
- The Black Grouse Alpha Edition (Marcel: 59 | Sascha: 60)
# Average
59
- Ben Bracken Speyside (Marcel: 59 | Sascha: 59)
55
- Dalmore Valour (Marcel: 55 | Sascha: 55)
50
- Ben Bracken Highland (Marcel: 50 | Sascha: 50)