Dun Naomhaig Bay Batch 2 2023 - Feinkost Reifferscheid
The 2023 Islay Single Malt Whisky, bottled by Feinkost Reifferscheid, is a characterful release without an age statement (No Age Statement), boasting a robust alcohol content of 56.0% ABV. As an independent bottler, Feinkost Reifferscheid has once again delivered a whisky that embodies the quintessential traits of the Isle of Islay.
Tasting Notes
Nose
Upon the first nosing, a complex aroma unfolds. Grassy notes harmoniously blend with sweet honey and a hint of hemp. An intense campfire smoke, accompanied by bacon-like nuances and a touch of BBQ sauce, adds depth to the whisky. Subtle hints of red bell pepper and toasted breadcrumbs round off the bouquet.
Palate
On the palate, the whisky is full-bodied and creamy. Dominant cold smoke and ashy notes define the initial impression. This is followed by fruity hints of passion fruit, imparting a certain freshness to the taste. Notes of fresh hay and heather complement the flavor profile, ensuring a balanced interplay between smoke and freshness.
Finish
The finish is long-lasting, spicy, and marked by pronounced oak notes. A sensation reminiscent of smoldering coal lingers, while the whisky maintains an overall puristic character.
🥃 We would like to give you the opportunity to participate in a private bottle sharing at cost price with this bottle.
To our bottle sharingsThoughts
Marcel 85/100
A real crowd-pleaser for Islay fans: this whisky delivers bold smoke alongside a lovely fruitiness that leaves you wanting more. Despite the high alcohol content, it feels lively and not overbearing – a fantastic companion for cozy evenings by the fire.
Sascha 86/100
This bottling impresses with a clear structure where smoky and fruity elements harmonize in perfect balance. The long-lasting oak notes and its minimalist character make it a fine example of a complex Islay whisky with excellent balance.
Value for Money: Excellent
💸 This whisky offers an outstanding value for money and is our value pick.
Discover our value for money winnersRelated Reviews
Kilchoman Batch Strength 2024
The Kilchoman Batch Strength 2024 is a whisky for real Islay fans. With a full 57.0 % ABV and no age statement, the Kilchoman Distillery focuses on pure intensity here. Those who love peaty smoke, maritime notes and honest cask strength will get their money's worth - but does this whisky also have enough character to stand out from the competition?
79/100
Port Ellen 1982 - Malts of Scotland
It's not every day that you get the chance to taste a 1982' Port Ellen (with no further age statement). So we are all the more delighted to be able to taste such a special dram. The distillery has not produced whisky since 1983, and a reopening is planned for this year. Getting hold of bottlings - especially at reasonable prices - is almost impossible at the moment.
93/100
Ardbeg 2017/2025 7 Years Bohemian Schnapsidee - VAME Malts
Neither finish nor distillery can be found on the label of the ‘Bohemian Schnapsidee’ from the German independent bottler VAME Malts from Munich. The website states: ‘A Wee Scottish beastie, matured in a cask that previously contained another famous Scottish drink.’ They refer to the finish as ‘Special Brew’. If you add up 1:1 here, you will quickly recognise the Ardbeg distillery with the Ardbeg Wee Beastie 5 Years and what can the Scottish speciality brew be other than Irn-Bru?Peat meets pop culture. And now ask yourself: Is this genius or madness? We are more than curious!
84/100Frequently Asked Questions
What sets the Dun Naomhaig Bay Batch 2 2023 apart from other Islay whiskies?
The Dun Naomhaig Bay Batch 2 2023 stands out through a combination of intense campfire smoke, bacon and BBQ notes, as well as fruity hints like passion fruit. The high bottling strength of 56% ABV enhances its full-bodied, creamy character and creates a well-balanced interplay between smoke and freshness.
How does the No Age Statement (NAS) character influence the taste of this whisky?
Since the Dun Naomhaig Bay Batch 2 2023 carries no age statement, the focus lies on maturation and the blending of different vintages. This allows for a complex aroma profile featuring fresh, grassy notes, intense smoky aromas, and a spicy oak influence on the finish, without the typical constraints of age declarations.
What is the best way to enjoy the Dun Naomhaig Bay Batch 2 2023 to fully experience its aromas?
To fully unlock its diverse aromas, it is recommended to enjoy the whisky neat or with a small splash of water. The water opens up the aromas, slightly softens the high strength, and highlights the fruity and herbal notes without diminishing the smoky character.