Betz Jamaica Rum Cask 2017/2022 Batch 1
The Betz distillery from Germany is known for its creative experiments - and the Jamaica Rum Cask Batch 1 is definitely one of them. With an ABV of 51.00 %, this whisky with an age statement of 5 years is a strong calibre that whets the appetite for Caribbean flavours right from the name. But does the whisky deliver what the rum cask promises? Well, let's put it this way: it's unforgettable. Unfortunately.
Tasting Notes
Nose
Tannins reminiscent of freshly polished wood meet a pungent citrus note - the lemon here seems more like the cheeky cousin who turns up uninvited to the party. This is joined by a sharp, almost chemical undertone that is slightly reminiscent of spirit. No trace of Caribbean warmth, but rather ‘Wuppertal in November’.
Palate
This is where it gets exciting, because the flavours are ... let's say ... idiosyncratic. There are vaguely sweetish notes reminiscent of overcooked sugar cane molasses before the 51% alcohol hits with full force. Light bitter notes dance on the tongue, followed by a woody spiciness and bitterness reminiscent of unripe fruit.
Finish
Oh, the finish is indeed impressive - but less in a positive sense. The spiciness really burns itself into the throat and leaves an aftershock that feels like it lasts forever. A rum finish? More like a fire finish. ‘Burns like hell’ sums it up perfectly.
Thoughts
Marcel 54/100
If you’re into wild experiments with plenty of punch, this delivers a genuine adventure – unfortunately one that feels more like a bumpy action movie than Caribbean lightness. Betz Jamaica Rum Cask Batch 1 is a dramatic ride that could be fun if it didn’t burn so unpleasantly.
Sascha 60/100
The balance between alcohol strength and flavors feels off, which severely limits the tasting experience. While there are hints of structural complexity, the dominant sharpness of 51% ABV overwhelms the subtle nuances of the rum finish, resulting in an overall rather rough impression.
Value for Money: Fair
Discover our value for money winnersRelated Reviews
St. Kilian Tag des Deutschen Whiskys (2023)
It's that time of year again. On the last Saturday in June, we celebrate the Day of the German Whisky. The St. Kilian Distillery is hosting its Whisky Festival for the second time. With great anticipation, we take this opportunity to closely examine the special edition from last year's festival. This time, it's the popular Hungarian oak from St. Kilian. The relatively small 95-liter casks impart a very rich color to this single malt, despite an aging period of just under five years.
81/100
Penderyn Madeira Finish
The Penderyn Madeira Finish Single Malt comes from Wales and thus from a rather untypical whisky region. What makes the Penderyn distillery unique is a so-called Faraday copper still, which is used in the production of the whisky. Matured in ex-bourbon casks and later in Madeira casks, the whisky is bottled in really chic bottles.
74/100
Glencadam Reserva Andalucia
With 46% ABV, uncoloured and non-chill filtered, this bottling promises honest craftsmanship. But can a NAS whisky, which was first matured in bourbon casks and then finished in Oloroso sherry butts, really convince? Or does the delicate Glencadam spirit disappear under the powerful sherry wave?
74/100Frequently Asked Questions
How does the Jamaica Rum Cask finish influence the flavor of the Betz Jamaica Rum Cask 2017/2022 Batch 1?
The rum cask finish imparts unusual aromas reminiscent more of cane molasses and woody bitterness. Instead of Caribbean sweetness, a sharp, almost chemical note dominates, culminating in an intense, burning finish.
Is the Betz Jamaica Rum Cask 2017/2022 Batch 1 drinkable without water despite its 51% alcohol content?
Due to the high 51% ABV and intense sharpness, the whisky may feel too strong and burning for many. Adding a little water is recommended to better perceive the flavors and soften the alcohol.
How does the Betz Jamaica Rum Cask 2017/2022 Batch 1 differ from classic German whiskies?
This whisky stands out because of its unusual rum cask finish, which leads to distinctive, sometimes sharp and bitter notes. Compared to classic German whiskies, it is noticeably more powerful and less balanced.