Mac-Talla 2009/2024 Feis Ile 2024 - Morrison Scotch Whisky Distillers
The Feis Ile bottlings are a highlight for Islay fans every year, and 2024 doesn't disappoint either: the Mac-Talla 2009/2024 Feis Ile from Morrison Scotch Whisky Distillers has everything you would expect from a classic, smoky dram - and a little bit more.
Tasting Notes
Nose
From the very first nosing, it is clear that a lot is happening in the glass. A strong plume of smoke meets burning elderberry, followed by a slightly leathery note reminiscent of well-worn leather shoes. This is joined by more unusual accents such as sweaty feet - yes, really - and a chalky freshness. But before that puts you off: the smoke skilfully softens the whole thing and is accompanied by sweet notes of caramel, blood orange and candy floss. A wild but fascinating combination.
Palate
The first sip brings with it an earthy spiciness, followed by an intense citrus note. Then the peat smoke hits with full force - almost like a whack-a-mole game with different smoke flavours that keep coming from different directions. However, the Mac-Talla not only remains smoky and strong, but also has a lovely sweetness reminiscent of dried fruit. A hint of turmeric gives the whole thing a spicy, slightly exotic flavour.
Finish
This shows that we are dealing with a well thought-out Islay whisky. The finish is long, full-bodied and remains earthy. A slightly nutty note resonates while the smoke slowly dissipates and leaves a pleasant warmth behind.
Thoughts
Marcel 81/100
This Mac-Talla 2009/2024 Feis Ile is a real fireworks display for the senses: smoky, sweet, and with a touch of madness – exactly what you expect from an Islay dram. A whisky that’s great fun and simply captivates with its complex aroma profile, even if the sweaty sock note is a bit daring. For fans who like to enjoy something off the beaten path, this is a bullseye!
Sascha 83/100
The Mac-Talla 2009/2024 impresses with an outstanding balance between intense peat smoke and complex sherry notes that give it depth and structure. The unusual but well-integrated aromas like chalky freshness and spicy turmeric speak to a thoughtful composition that harmoniously rounds off the long, earthy finish. A technically solid example of modern Islay whisky with character.
Value for Money: Fair
Discover our value for money winnersRelated Reviews
Dun Naomhaig Bay Batch 1 2022 - Feinkost Reifferscheid
The 2022 single malt whisky, bottled by Feinkost Reifferscheid, hails from Scotland's Isle of Islay, a region renowned for its robust and smoky whiskies. As an independent bottler, Feinkost Reifferscheid has once again demonstrated its expertise with this release.
86/100
Ardbeg Scorch Committee Release
Ardbeg's Committee Release 2021 was the Scorch. The malt was stored in extremely burnt out ex-bourbon barrels. The associated story tells of a dragon that was resident in Ardbeg's Warehouse 3.As usual for Ardbeg, this Committee Release Malt is only available for purchase directly from Ardbeg on Ardbeg Day. Probably, very few bottles actually make it to the tasting - most will probably stand locked in collector's cabinets.
76/100
Ardbeg Ardcore Committee Release
Inspired by the punk past from the 1970s, Ardbeg releases Ardcore as this year's committee release. By the way, it is said to taste "like biting a spiky ball".The releases are very polarising. Very interesting for collectors and sold out just as quickly, those who want to taste the latest Committee release often don't get their money's worth.
74/100Frequently Asked Questions
What makes the Mac-Talla 2009/2024 Feis Ile from Morrison Scotch Whisky Distillers stand out compared to other Islay whiskies?
The Mac-Talla 2009/2024 Feis Ile is distinguished by its complex aroma profile, which alongside classic peat smoke also offers unusual notes like burning elderberry, chalky freshness, and even a slight leathery touch. This combination of intense smokiness and sweet nuances such as caramel and blood orange makes it particularly multifaceted.
How should you best enjoy the Mac-Talla 2009/2024 Feis Ile to fully experience its aromas?
It’s best enjoyed neat at room temperature to optimally perceive the complex aromas like peat smoke, citrus notes, and dried fruits. A large nosing glass helps the scent unfold, and a few drops of water can help soften the intensity of the smoke.
What does the designation 'Independent bottler' mean for Morrison Scotch Whisky Distillers regarding this whisky?
As an independent bottler, Morrison Scotch Whisky Distillers purchases the whisky from the distillery and bottles it themselves. This often allows for limited editions with unique flavor profiles that can differ from the distillery’s standard releases. The Mac-Talla 2009/2024 Feis Ile is therefore a special selection not directly from the distillery.