Tomintoul 16 Years
Tomintoul's single malts are known to be among the lighter, smoother - and, as some would say, old-fashioned and boring - Speyside malts. Perhaps because of this and the high demand for intense and powerful Scotches, the distillery flies under the radar of most people.
Tasting Notes
Nose
Well-ordered, orange, hazelnut and dried fruit are found as base aromas. In the background, malty-grainy and slightly floral (daisies?) notes are distributed. We also find some bitter orange, honey and oats, which are infused and character-building.
Palate
The goal is quite clear. This whisky from the Speyside wants to be soft and velvety. Buttercrossaint and toasted sesame, as well as light citrus notes we find alongside a little toasted oak, marzipan (almonds) and walnut nuttiness. A little white pepper here and there, and that's it.
Finish
This malt finishes medium-bodied, clean and warming, with almond, oat and oak tones.
Thoughts
Marcel 76/100
The Tomintoul 16 Years presents itself as pleasantly restrained and smooth, ideal for those who prefer no wild experiments. It scores with light nutty and fruity notes but overall remains a bit too tame and generic to truly excite – yet it’s still enjoyable in the glass.
Sascha 75/100
The 16-years release from Tomintoul is balanced and cleanly structured, without any sharp edges or roughness. For lovers of light Speyside malts, the balance is well achieved, but the profile remains conventional and lacks distinctive character, making this whisky more suited for mass consumption than for connoisseurs.
Value for Money: Fair
Discover our value for money winnersRelated Reviews
Speyburn 16 Years
When you hear ‘Travel Exclusive’, you immediately think of something special, something that you can only get hold of with difficulty when travelling, don't you? Well, the Speyburn 16 years fulfils this claim... but not in a positive sense.
66/100
Allt-a-Bhainne 17 Years 2005 Infrequent Flyers - Alistair Walker Whisky Company
When a whisky comes from the Speyside region and has an impressive 60.1% vol., the expectations are clear: intensity, complexity and a touch of adventure. This is exactly what the Alistair Walker Whisky Company delivers with its bottling of Allt-a-Bhainne 2005 from the ‘Infrequent Flyers’ series. But how does this 17-years drop really perform in the glass?
81/100
Glenfarclas 21 Years
There are moments in the life of a whisky lover when you stand in front of a glass and know that you will never experience this again. Glenfarclas 21 years is just such a moment - a whisky that is no longer produced and has therefore become a liquid time capsule. Like an old friend that you can only visit in memories.
82/100Frequently Asked Questions
How does the Tomintoul 16 Years differ from other Speyside whiskies?
The Tomintoul 16 Years is an especially light and gentle Speyside malt that relies less on intense smoke or peat notes. Instead, fruity and nutty aromas dominate, making it more accessible and softer than many other whiskies from the region.
What aromas can I expect when tasting the Tomintoul 16 Years?
On the nose, you’ll find notes of orange, hazelnut, and dried fruits, complemented by malty and floral nuances. On the palate, it is soft with flavors of butter croissant, toasted sesame, citrus, marzipan, and walnuts, rounded off by a subtle spice of white pepper.
Is the Tomintoul 16 Years suitable for mixing cocktails?
Due to its mild and velvety character, the Tomintoul 16 Years is better suited for neat enjoyment or light whisky cocktails that don’t overpower its delicate flavors. It is less suitable for strong or smoky drinks.