Lot No. 40 Rye Whisky
Nose
First, there is a surprisingly fruity note of fresh apple juice, which blends with the characteristic rye spice. It is like walking through an autumn garden while a baker's oven sizzles next door. The oak makes its presence felt confidently – a lot of oak, in fact, which gives the whole thing structure and depth. Then comes the sweet seduction: caramel creeps in, creamy and inviting.
But Lot No. 40 has a few more tricks up its sleeve: cooling menthol provides freshness and awakens the senses, while bread-like notes are reminiscent of freshly baked rye bread. The caraway at the end is not intrusive, but rather like a knowing wink – yes, rye is definitely at work here. This nose is a promise that you definitely want to redeem on the palate.
Taste
The first thing you notice is a pleasant dryness that prepares your mouth for what is to come. Then honey unfolds on the tongue, sweet but not sticky, accompanied by a subtle melon note that provides a refreshing fruitiness.
The menthol and herbal notes from the nose return, this time with a slightly cooling effect that adds an invigorating dimension to the whole. It is this balance between sweet and spicy, between soft and structured, that makes Lot No. 40 so drinkable.
Finish
The finish is medium-long and warming – exactly what you would expect from a good rye. The spiciness that has been present throughout the tasting comes to the fore once again here, leaving a pleasant tingling sensation. Caramel and brown sugar give the finish a sweet note that prevents it from becoming too dry.
Thoughts
Lot No. 40 Rye Whisky is an excellent ambassador for Canadian rye whisky. It impressively demonstrates that rye does not always have to be aggressive and demanding. Its mildness makes it the ideal introductory whisky for anyone who wants to discover the world of rye without being overwhelmed by an avalanche of spice. The rye character is clearly recognisable, but in a very accessible form. For connoisseurs, however, this very accessibility could be a double-edged sword. Lot No. 40 is very well made, but it sometimes lacks the depth and complexity found in higher-priced ryes.
Support us and purchase on Amazon*Rating: 71/100 - Very Good (Marcel: 72 | Sascha: 70)
Value for Money: 4/5 - Good
Preview Image Source: Whiskybase
FAQ: The Most Common Questions
❓ How does Lot No. 40 compare to American rye whiskey?
👉 Lot No. 40 is significantly milder and more accessible than most American ryes. While US ryes often boast intense spice and sharpness, the Canadian representative focuses on balance. The rye notes are clearly recognisable, but embedded in a gentle matrix of fruit and sweetness. American rye fans who are used to high-proof spirits may find it too tame, but for beginners it is just right.
❓ Should I drink Lot No. 40 neat, or is it also suitable for cocktails?
👉 Lot No. 40 is extremely versatile. Enjoyed neat, it unfolds its full flavour profile and shows what Canadian rye is capable of. Thanks to its mildness and 43% ABV, it is also an excellent cocktail whisky – it cuts a fine figure in a Manhattan or Old Fashioned in particular. The rye spice remains present in mixed drinks without dominating. Our tip: try it neat first, then experiment!