High West Double Rye Whiskey

2025-10-22 🇩🇪 Zum deutschen Testbericht
The High West Distillery is located in Utah - a state that is usually better known for Mormons and skiing than for whiskey. But hey, sometimes the best surprises come from the most unexpected places! The distillery is located in the Wasatch-Uinta Mountains and is the first legal distillery in Utah since 1870.
The Double Rye with its 46% vol. is, as the name suggests, double: two different rye whiskeys are married here. It's like pairing two different herb gardens together and hoping they get along well.
High West Double Rye Whiskey
High West Double Rye Whiskey (@whiskyedition)
Rye Whiskey | No Age Statement | 46,00 % ABV. | 57,00 €/l | Distillery: High West Distillery | made in USA
We would like to give you the opportunity to participate in a private bottle sharing at cost price with this bottle. Take a look: Bottle Sharing

Nose

This nose is very fresh - almost cooling, as if someone had thrown a menthol candy into the whiskey. The many herbs are so present that you would almost expect Brother Benedict to come round the corner and offer a cough syrup.
Particularly striking: the dill! Who would have thought that a whiskey would smell of the spice that normally ends up on cucumbers? It is joined by mint, which is so intense that it is almost menthol-like. The rye bread completes the picture - and makes you really hungry for a proper evening meal.

Taste

The rye spice immediately comes into its own, followed by some caramel - but be careful, it doesn't get sweet! It's as if the caramel is saying, "I'm here, but I'm not making a big deal out of it." Very subtle, very grown-up.
The herbs are back - and so strong that it almost tastes like cough syrup. But the good cough syrup that you secretly liked as a child (admit it!). The whole thing is very much built on the botanical side, as if a botanist had decided to make whiskey instead of tea.
Surprisingly, it's not terribly intense, although it is very flavoursome.

Finish

The exit is short and concise - like a good joke. It comes, does its job and disappears again without overdoing it. It finishes spicy and oaky, with a hint of vanilla and a slightly dry note.

Thoughts

The High West Double Rye is pleasantly different - like a hipster that is actually cool. It goes well in the summer, which is quite special for a whiskey. Most whiskeys are more like winter mates, but this one is like a refreshing herbal tea with alcohol.

Support us and purchase on Amazon*

Rating: 75/100 - Very Good (Marcel: 73 | Sascha: 77)

Value for Money: 3/5 - Ok

Would you like to buy the bottling? Support us and purchase on Amazon*. You don not pay more than the usual price, but we get a small percentage of the purchase price. This way we can cover the running costs of the website and remain free of advertising.
*Information on the Amazon Affiliate Programme
Preview Image Source: Whiskybase
Further Information Batch 21G30

FAQ: The Most Common Questions

❓ Is this really a whiskey or a herbal liqueur?

👉 The intense herbal flavours come from the high rye content and the special distillation method. It is definitely whiskey!

❓ Why does it smell of dill? That's funny!

👉 The dill notes come from the rye and are typical of many American rye whiskies. It's like asking why Islay whiskies smell of the sea - it's just part of the character.

❓ Can you also drink it in winter or only in summer?

👉 Of course you can also drink it in winter! The summer recommendation comes from the fact that it is more refreshing than most whiskies.

Contact us
About us
How we evaluate