Strathisla 24 Year Old 1992/2016 - Malts of Scotland
Nose
The composition begins waxy, almost like the interior of an old library, where leather and beeswax seal the shelves. Then a floral bouquet opens up, which seems surprisingly feminine for a self-proclaimed "sturdy male" – as if he were wearing a heart of wildflowers under his lumberjack shirt.
The fragrance is not intrusive, not like an overzealous perfumery department, but subtle and sophisticated, like the discreet scent of a well-groomed gentleman of the old school. Forest honey covers it like a golden veil – not the industrially clarified supermarket honey, but that dark, resinous forest honey with personality and history. Vanilla joins in, but not as a soloist, rather as a member of an ensemble that knows when to step back.
And then, the wood. Lots of wood. But not that young, aggressive oak that screams "I'm here!", but the dignified wood of old furniture, polished by decades. Apricot and pear dance on the edge, dried fruits that have exchanged their sweetness for velvety depth. And – oh yes – green tobacco. Not the smoky cigarette, but the fresh leaves in the drying barn, earthy and aromatic.
Taste
We noted it as "sparkling" – that electrifying tingle on the tongue that signifies life. Spicy, yes, but not one-dimensionally spicy. It's as if someone had knocked over a Michelin-starred chef's spice cabinet and then decided that the chaos was perfect.
Full-bodied and oily, this whisky envelops the mouth like a well-fitting winter coat – protection and luxury at the same time. "Has power" is an understatement. It doesn't just have power, it IS power. But this power is never crude. The oak, oh that wonderful oak, presents itself in its most mature form – not bitter, not tannic, but wise and balanced.
The complexity is what elevates this palate from good to extraordinary. While you are still trying to decipher the spice, the next wave of flavours has already built up. Fruit mingles with wood, sweetness with tartness, creaminess with precision. It's like reading a good novel – each page reveals new nuances without losing the thread.
Finish
He stays, takes a book from your shelf, sits down in your best armchair and makes himself comfortable. The soft oak – and here its true age shows – dominates, but with the gentleness of an old sage who imparts his lessons without raising his voice.
A hint of iodine creeps in, unexpected for a Speysider, but welcome – a maritime whisper amidst the landlocked elegance. Garden herbs, perhaps thyme, perhaps sage, round off the finish, as if someone had wandered through a herb garden on the way out. The finish is not spectacular in the sense of fireworks and fanfare, but spectacular in its consistency and depth.
Thoughts
"That's a sturdy dog" – sometimes a spontaneous remark hits the nail on the head better than any carefully crafted phrase. This Strathisla is masculine without being toxic, powerful without being domineering, complex without being confusing. The comparison with a "good evening herbal tea" may sound curious at first, but it captures this wonderful duality: calming and stimulating at the same time, soothing and invigorating.
"It's just awesome" – in its unacademic directness, perhaps the most honest assessment. And: "There's not much more room for improvement." In fact, this 24-year-old moves in spheres where the air is thin. Compared to official Strathisla bottlings (which are rare anyway), this Malts of Scotland selection shows what the distillery can achieve without compromise.
This whisky is not for beginners, and that's a good thing. It is aimed at those who have already mastered the basics and are ready for the master class.
Rating: 95/100 - World Class (Marcel: 96 | Sascha: 93)
FAQ: The Most Common Questions
❓ Why is this Strathisla, with an alcohol content of 56.2%, not aggressively sharp?
👉 This is the magic of long maturation. After 24 years in the cask, the whisky has developed an oily, full-bodied texture that beautifully integrates the high alcohol content.
❓ What does "sturdy dog" actually mean in whisky parlance?
👉 "Sturdy Dog" is a charmingly unacademic way of saying: this whisky has character, backbone and self-confidence. It is not tame, not overly smooth, not pleasing to the point of insignificance. It has rough edges, but the right ones. It has rough edges, but the right ones. Like a well-dressed gentleman with an interesting past – cultured, but not tame. Compared to many modern whiskies that are tailored for maximum accessibility, this Strathisla stands by its personality. It expects you to take the time to understand it – and generously rewards that investment.